Monday, April 27, 2026 at 6:40 PM EDT

St. Louis Cardinals @ Pittsburgh Pirates

STL @ PIT

Scheduled

Moneyline

STL

45%

55%

PIT

+116-128

ML Edge

STL+6.5%

PIT-6.5%

Total (O/U)

8.0

BetOnline.ag

Over+3.8%

Under-3.8%

Venue

Park Factor

1.00

Neutral

Away Starter

Team:St. Louis Cardinals (STL)

Pitcher:Dustin May(RHP)

Record:3-2

ERA:5.84

Home Starter

Team:Pittsburgh Pirates (PIT)

Pitcher:Mason Montgomery(RHP)

Record:1-0

ERA:3.97

💡 Betting Insights

Key takeaways for this matchup

💰

STL ML has a 6.5% edge — the market may be undervaluing them.

📊

The Under has a 3.8% edge.

🎯

Top prop: Jake Mangum OVER 0.5 batter hits (68% win prob).

⚾

Pitching matchup: Dustin May (5.84 ERA) vs Mason Montgomery (3.97 ERA).

Player Props

50 props available for this game

⚾ Batting Props (48)

Player	Prop	Line	Odds	Win %	Quality
Jake Mangum	OVER hits	0.5	-263	68%	54.1
Alec Burleson	OVER hits	0.5	-208	67%	53.5
Oneil Cruz	OVER total bases	0.5	-263	69%	50.6
Alec Burleson	OVER total bases	0.5	-263	69%	50.6
JJ Wetherholt	OVER doubles	0.5	+475	20%	50.5
Alec Burleson	UNDER hits	1.5	-263	68%	50.2
Jake Mangum	OVER total bases	0.5	-238	67%	49.6
Nick Gonzales	OVER total bases	0.5	-233	67%	49.4
Nick Gonzales	OVER hits	0.5	-222	66%	48.9
Ivan Herrera	OVER total bases	0.5	-200	66%	48.8
Ivan Herrera	OVER hits	0.5	-200	65%	48.5
Nick Yorke	OVER hits	0.5	-213	64%	47.9
Oneil Cruz	OVER hits	0.5	-200	64%	47.9
Ryan O'Hearn	OVER hits	0.5	-189	64%	47.8
Jordan Walker	OVER hits	0.5	-185	63%	47.7

🎯 Pitching Props (2)

Player	Prop	Line	Odds	Win %	Quality
Dustin May	OVER strikeouts	3.5	-278	68%	50.2
Dustin May	UNDER strikeouts	5.5	-233	65%	48.7

Pitcher Matchup Analysis

Platoon splits, recent form, and times through the order

ESPN Win Probability

STL

PIT

37.7%62.3%

Dustin May (STL)

2026 season

Split	ERA	WHIP	K/9	BB/9	AVG	IP
Overall	5.84	1.57	7.4	1.9	.337	24.2
Home	4.50	1.38	6.2	1.1	.317	16.0
Away	8.31	1.95	9.9	3.3	.371	8.2
Last 7 Days	1.69	1.37	8.8	1.8	.286	5.1
Last 30 Days	5.84	1.57	7.4	1.9	.337	24.2

Opponent Batting by Handedness

Split	AVG	OBP	SLG	OPS	AB	K
vs LHB	.391	.437	.625	1.062	64	11
vs RHB	.235	.257	.324	.581	34	9

Times Through Order

Time	AVG	OBP	SLG	OPS	AB	K
1st Time	.381	.422	.595	1.017	42	11
2nd Time	.317	.356	.463	.819	41	7
3rd Time	.267	.313	.467	.779	15	2

Mason Montgomery (PIT)

2026 season

Split	ERA	WHIP	K/9	BB/9	AVG	IP
Overall	3.97	1.53	17.0	4.9	.244	11.1
Home	1.93	1.43	19.3	0.0	.300	4.2
Away	5.40	1.77	17.4	8.7	.200	6.2
Last 7 Days	0.00	0.50	9.0	4.5	.000	2.0
Last 30 Days	2.70	1.30	17.1	2.7	.250	10.0

Opponent Batting by Handedness

Split	AVG	OBP	SLG	OPS	AB	K
vs LHB	.143	.294	.143	.437	14	10
vs RHB	.290	.353	.452	.805	31	11

Times Through Order

Time	AVG	OBP	SLG	OPS	AB	K
1st Time	.244	.333	.356	.689	45	21
2nd Time	.000	.000	.000	.000	0	0
3rd Time	.000	.000	.000	.000	0	0

Last 5 Games

PIT: W L W W L

STL: W L L L L

Season Series

Season (13 games)

Weather

72°F

Condition: 3

Recent Odds

Latest betting lines from various books

Moneyline

Book	Away	Home	Time
BetOnline.ag	+116	-128	4:42 PM
LowVig.ag	+116	-128	4:42 PM
MyBookie.ag	+114	-135	4:42 PM
BetUS	+116	-127	4:42 PM
Bovada	+113	-135	4:42 PM

Totals

Book	Total	Over	Under	Time
BetOnline.ag	8.0	-103	-118	4:42 PM
LowVig.ag	8.0	+100	-115	4:42 PM
MyBookie.ag	8.0	-105	-116	4:42 PM
BetUS	8.0	-105	-115	4:42 PM
Bovada	8.5	-115	-105	4:42 PM